GOAT-MEN's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[TomFulp]

A for effort in this case, decent animation styling, but man the audio was a wreck, not very applealing the the audience if they have to refer to a script, maybe keep the animation, and re work the audio, if your needing voice work, hit me up, otherwise my advice is slow down a bit, work with the voice a bit, find your range to where you can pull it off, but at the same time its audible. overall 3.5/5 5/5 (cause Fulp is DA man)

Kolumbo responds:

thanks man

[The Muffin Man]

I'v seen alot of "lol omfg thats so cool of a video" but how about a real review? I'v been on the site for 9+ years and have seen hundreds of vids, but this one jumps out at me in the originality department.

Lets start with the positive, firstly the thing that sparked my interest was the Real Life television show preaching religion, I dont see alot of RL/animation hybrid's anymore, esp. to further the plot of the video, props.

Next I'd like to say the way you twisted a child's song into a beautifully crafted horror short, its got everything a proper horror flick needs creepy antagonist, gore, and small children. You have really outdone yourself.

Now on to the negative, which I believe every artist needs to hear to further they're creative/technical prowess.

There are not many things negative about your work, but I did see a few things, mainly the large file size, took me awhile to actually watch this, and then there was a little rigidness about your characters, maybe in the future work on smoothing them out? Nothing too bad though.

Overall this was a great movie, and again props to you for originality and inovation, 5/5- 4.5/5- 10/10
I hope to see some more work from you of this caliber.

Best Regards,
_-Ze Goat-_

Gi-go responds:

Thanks very much, I appreciate these reviews.

I didn't mean to throw in any kind of message with the Christian children's show, but in the low budget creepy department, nothing in the world beats those shows, and I do love live action hybrids.

The file size is actually pretty small for a video file, perhaps they're working out some kinks in the NG player? Try out the vimeo version on my site, that might run more smoothly.

Thanks again sir!